We are open! Click here to read about our COVID-19 safety measures
New Holland: 717-354-2003

The Best of CertainTeed, James Hardie & Mastic Siding Colors

Changing the color of your siding is like changing the color of your hair – it has an impact on not only the way it looks, but the way you feel! According to recent studies, updating your home’s exterior look can increase it’s value, and can boast a 100% return on investment. Plus, everything deserves a little makeover every once and a while!

At Choice Windows, we only install the best siding options for our customers. That’s why we so strongly recommend selecting a shade from James Hardie, Mastic, or CertainTeed siding colors options.

Buckle up as we drive straight into the best siding colors from each of our favorite manufactures.


Mastic Siding Colors That Will Wow:

2019 has been a big year in Mastic siding colors as many new hues and skews have been released for homeowners to take advantage of. One of the reasons why many customers choose Mastic vinyl siding is because of their low maintenance yet luxury aesthetic.

When working with Mastic siding colors, it’s easy to mix and match colors and textures to create the perfect home exterior for your individual style. Below are just a few of the Mastic siding colors and combinations we love for this season!


Quiet Willow

Quiet Willow Mastic siding color

Naturally, natural colored siding tends to be a favorite among homeowners that love to spend time outdoors, or who live in a more rural environment. Coupled together with white trim and shutters creates a lovely farmhouse feel.


Newport Bay with Deep Granite

Mastic solar defense siding

One of the biggest color duos sweeping the nation is gray and blue – translated into Mastic siding color terms: Newport Bay and Deep Granite! Either one of these rich shades standalone as a stunning choice, but when paired together, they create a true modern masterpiece.


Misty Shadow & Pebblestone Clay

Two-toned Mastic siding with tan and brown

Another dynamic duo in the Mastic siding color world is Misty Shadow and Pebblestone Clay. This subtle warm-tone scheme introduces neutrals to your exterior with sophistication. While both of these colors look fabulous on their own, together, they create a unique twist on a timeless classic palette.

Seeing is believing, and to believe how great your home will look with a new Mastic siding colors, their team has created a home exterior visualizer to use for free! Check out ALL of your Mastic siding color options on the website or by using the color visualizer above.

Get Pricing


Subtle CertainTeed Siding Colors:   

Only one company can boast the “best siding in the industry” – and that is CertainTeed! Rightfully so, the brand has worked hard to offer durable exterior siding options that last for years on end. At Choice Windows, we choose to carry and install all CertainTeed siding colors because of their lowkey statement shades, and low-maintenance.

Check out our top 3 CertainTeed siding colors.

Autumn Yellow

Pale yellow house siding in Lancaster PA

An easy way to overcome your fear of color on your home is to start here! Light and carefree, Autumn yellow is the Certainteed siding color that is bold enough to stand out, yet subtle enough to not to raise any eyebrows. Gray home after gray home, your Autumn Yellow will be a breath of fresh air! It’s perfect for your beach home or casual cul-de-sac.


Oxford Blue:

Blue Certainteed siding on single-story home

Out of all CertainTeeds’ siding colors, Oxford is easily takes the blue ribbon. This season’s biggest design trend is shades of blues and grays, and Oxford Blue really pulls the two together beautifully. At Choice Windows, we’re big fans of matching CertainTeed’s siding color Oxford Blue with a subdued Pacific Blue trim (like shown in the photo) – for obvious reasons.


Silver Ash

Silver Certainteed siding color on home

Light colors add volume and interest to any size home – that’s why we love Silver Ash from CertainTeed. If your home’s exterior has a handful of design elements, like stonework or roof pitches, closely related colors will unify its unique design! Silver Ash is one of the Certainteed siding colors that compliments stonework so well.

Find Your Match


James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding Colors:  

James Hardie is the leading siding manufacturer making earth-toned statement shades that would make Mother Earth proud – and not just for their muted colors but for the eco-friendly benefits.

The best part? James Hardie has Baked-on ColorPlus® Technology that guarantees you greater resistance to fading, chipping, and cracking. Less maintenance for you, longer lifespan for your home. Below are just a few of the 15 fiber cement siding colors gaining momentum this season:

Artic White

Artic white house siding on front porch

If you’re raising a white-flag to color this year, Artic White is the siding color for you. As the trend of simple, minimalism home interiors continue to pick up speed, so does James Hardie’s Artic White fiber cement siding color. Don’t let the light and bright vibes deceive you – despite its light color, it is actually eminently easy to clean, and low-maintenance.


Iron Gray

James Hardie fiber cement siding on farmhouse

You may not think that a neutral can be bold, but we bet the James Hardie fiber cement siding color of Iron Gray will change your mind. The dramatic yet elegant feel of Iron Gray is the shade to choose for your modern farmhouse or standout-townhome. Because of it’s neutrality, trim color options are truly endless. However, a few of our favorite options are a crisp white or industrial black.


Mountain Sage

Mountain Sage is a shade that is neither too light nor too dark – we guess you could call it, “the green in-between”! With contrasting white trim or natural wood accent pieces, you can create a warm mood in an understated way with this soft James Hardie fiber cement siding color.

Whichever fiber cement siding color stimulates your style senses, make sure that you work with an experienced siding installer like Choice Windows. If not installed correctly, no matter which siding color you choose, it will quickly begin to collect moisture damage!

Get Curb Appeal


Selecting Your Siding Color & Installer from Lancaster PA

Whether you’ve just hatched a color palette idea or know exactly the shade and brand you want, Choice Windows is here and happy to help. Our installation teams are fast, tidy, and eager to work with you.

With free price quotes, free color samples, and free professional advice – what do you have to lose? Get started today on giving your home the colorful upgrade it deserves!

“Share” on Bloglovin!

Share This:


View Our Google Reviews

Hey review readers! Defiantly check this place out for all your home remodel/replacement needs. The showroom is awesome and full of great products to choose from. You'll be disappointed if you don't!
lisa lopez
lisa lopez
19:51 04 Jan 21
Great team, great place and Matilde is awesome! I’d totally recommend! No complaints!
Sara O’Brien
Sara O’Brien
15:09 15 Dec 20
Excellent!!! Chad and Ashley were personable and responsive. Matt did a perfect install of a sliding deck door. He was punctual, skilled, and neat. Couldn't have asked for more! Thank you!
Donna Milewski
Donna Milewski
14:38 13 Dec 20
Thank you to Tim and Jeff for a great job! I love my new door!
Wendy Hammond
Wendy Hammond
11:46 01 Dec 20
Carla Oneill
Carla Oneill
22:13 24 Nov 20
The Lancaster Chamber of Commerce & Industry Building Industry Association of Lancaster County National Kitchen & Bath Association EPA BBB Angie's List Houszz LNP Award Choice Windows 2018